Patch it. For most holes and cracks in Central Florida homes, drywall repair is the right call, not a new sheet. Cavender Drywall prices most single-hole or single-crack repairs at $370 to $605, and a small hole of about 4 inches or less is usually around $370. Replace the whole sheet when the damage takes up most of it, when water has softened the board, or when the framing behind it is damaged.
The price depends on the size of the damage, the ceiling height and how much texture has to be matched. Small repairs are often one visit. Anything needing three coats of mud runs across two visits, because the mud has to dry properly between coats. A full sheet has no flat price. It is quoted from a photo, based on how much board comes out, how high it sits and how much texture work it needs. We're based in Minneola and work across Lake and Orange counties, from Clermont and Groveland to Winter Garden, Ocoee and Apopka.
When should you repair drywall instead of replacing it?
Repair it when the board around the damage is dry and solid, even if the hole itself looks bad. These are all standard patch jobs:
- a doorknob or furniture hole
- a crack running from the corner of a door or window
- a failed patch somebody else did
- an opening left after a licensed plumber or electrician has finished (we only do the drywall; the plumbing or wiring stays with the licensed trade)
On holes, we cut back to sound board and add backing where the hole needs it, so the patch has something solid behind it, rather than stretching mesh tape over an open hole. Then we set the patch flush and build it up in thin coats, with drying time between them. A bigger hole is still a repair. It just takes more coats, and that can mean a second visit. Damage along a taped seam can take longer, depending on how much of the tape has let go.
You get a price from a photo before anything is booked. If what we find on site changes it, we tell you before any work starts. Everything a repair includes is on our drywall repair service page.
When do you need to replace the whole sheet?
Replace it when there isn't enough sound, dry board left to patch into. That comes down to three things:
- The damage takes up most of the sheet. A standard sheet is 4 by 8 feet. Once most of it is broken, soft or cut up, a new piece makes more sense than patching around what's left.
- Water has softened the board. If the core is wet, spongy or crumbling, a patch won't hold, and the moisture keeps working into the board around it. The leak has to be fixed first. If it's coming from the roof, a pipe or the AC, that's a job for a licensed roofer, plumber or AC tech.
- The framing behind it is damaged. If a stud is cracked, bent or rotted, new drywall won't fix what's underneath. That's a job for a general contractor or framer, and your city or county building department can tell you whether it needs a permit. We put the drywall back once they're done.
One more case where you should stop before anyone patches anything. A long or widening crack, or one that keeps coming back after a patch, can point to settling or movement in the structure. Have a structural engineer or general contractor look at it first. Once they've cleared it, we can close the wall back up.
How can you tell if the board is wet or the damage is serious?
Press on the board around the damage. If it's firm and dry, it can usually be patched. If it's soft, spongy, crumbly or ringed with a brown stain, water has got in. Three quick checks before you text us:
- Press gently around the damage. Firm is good. Soft, spongy or crumbly board means the core has taken on water.
- Look for a brown ring or yellowing, or a stain spreading out from the damage. That points to water, and the source needs finding before any board goes back.
- Watch the crack. If it has grown since you first noticed it, or it came back after an earlier patch, mention that.
Never paint over a damp or stained spot to hide it. Anything still wet inside the board usually bleeds back through. Text one close-up and one photo from across the room, and tell us what you found. Plenty of damage that looks bad is still a patch, and a photo is the quickest way to know.
Repair vs replacement: price, visits and mess
| Factor | Drywall repair | Sheet replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Most single repairs $370 to $605; a hole of about 4 inches or less usually around $370 | No flat price; quoted from a photo, based on how much board comes out, ceiling height and texture |
| Coats of mud | Thin coats with drying time between each; bigger patches take more | New seams and screw heads taped and coated in thin layers |
| Visits | Small repairs often one visit; two when three coats are needed | Often two or more, since new seams usually need three coats; your quote gives the expected timeline |
| Dust and mess | Light on a small patch; drop cloths and a careful clean-up | More, because more board comes out and more finishing is needed; plastic sheeting and HEPA vacuum clean-up |
| Texture | Matched to the wall and feathered past the patch | Same job over a bigger area, feathered past the new board |
For holes, cracks and damage that hasn't soaked the board, a repair is the smaller job, with less board out and less mess. For more on visits and drying time, see how long drywall repair takes, and for prices, see what drywall repair costs in Central Florida.
The texture problem with repair, and why it matters
Most homes around here have textured walls, usually knockdown or orange peel. A smooth patch in a knockdown wall is easy to spot in side light, even under good paint. That's why a lot of patches still show years later.
We put more care into matching texture than into any other part of the job. We match knockdown and orange peel to the surrounding wall and feather the texture out past the patch, so the edge blends in instead of stopping abruptly. Popcorn ceilings are the exception. A popcorn patch almost never blends, so on a popcorn ceiling we would usually recommend removing and retexturing the whole ceiling instead.
A new sheet doesn't skip this step. It goes in untextured, so it still has to be matched and blended out past the new board. If the match is wrong, the new sheet shows as clearly as a bad patch.
How long does a properly done patch last?
A patch done properly should hold up for years, as long as there's no new water or impact damage. "Properly done" means three things:
- each coat dried before the next went on
- the texture matched the wall
- the edges were feathered out past the patch
That's what makes a patch last, but it isn't a warranty. What we do guarantee: if a patch shows through the paint within 30 days, we come back and touch it up. The limits are in our Terms.
A rushed patch, with thick mud loaded on in one pass, can shrink as it dries and show its outline or crack. A patch also shows when the texture doesn't match or the feathering stops short. In the humid summer months mud takes longer to dry, so the wait between coats matters even more. Thin coats, real drying time and matched texture are what make a patch blend in instead of fail.
Can you fix drywall yourself?
Sometimes. A small hole of about 4 inches or less in a smooth wall can be a manageable DIY job if you're patient with thin coats. Thin coats with drying time between them aren't optional.
On a textured wall, which is most walls around here, matching the texture is the hard part, and DIY patches often show. A failed DIY patch usually has to be redone, and that can mean repainting the wall. If you're not sure it's worth the bother, text us a photo. You get a price before anything is booked, and if what we find on site changes it, we tell you before any work starts. For the usual trouble spots, see where DIY drywall repair goes wrong.
How much dust does drywall repair or replacement make?
A small patch makes little dust and usually needs only drop cloths and a careful clean-up before we leave. Bigger repairs, sheet replacements and anything with heavy sanding make more, and on those Cavender Drywall uses plastic sheeting and HEPA vacuum clean-up. We take dust seriously. If anyone at home has breathing problems, or you have pets or small kids, tell us when you text so we can plan the setup around it.
Get a price for your repair
Text a close-up, a photo from across the room and your address to (352) 995-3511. Mention any staining or soft board. We reply with a price, then agree a date with you. If what we find on site changes the price, you hear about it before any work starts. Drywall is what we do. We patch the wall, match the texture and prime it ready for paint, or paint it if you want, so you're not chasing a separate painter. You don't have to sit through a two-hour appointment window just to get a number.
Quick answers
Is it cheaper to repair or replace drywall?
Most holes and cracks only need a patch, and Cavender Drywall prices most single-hole or single-crack repairs at $370 to $605. The price depends on size, ceiling height and how much texture matching is involved. A small hole of about 4 inches or less is usually around $370. A full sheet, or anything outside that range, is quoted from a photo before anything is booked.
When do I have to replace the whole sheet instead of patching?
Replace it when there isn't enough sound, dry board left to patch into. That happens when the damage takes up most of the sheet, when water has softened the core, or when the framing behind it is damaged. If the board around the damage is firm and dry, it can be patched.
How can I tell if my drywall is wet or soft?
Press gently around the damage. Firm board is fine. Soft, spongy or crumbly board has taken on water, and so has board with a brown ring or a spreading stain. The leak has to be fixed before any drywall goes back. If you're not sure, text Cavender Drywall a close-up and a wide photo and we'll tell you what we see.
How long does a drywall patch last?
If a patch shows through the paint within 30 days, Cavender Drywall comes back and touches it up. The limits are in our Terms. Beyond that, a patch done in thin coats with matched, feathered texture should hold up for years unless there is new water or impact damage. A rushed patch with thick mud in one pass can shrink as it dries and show its outline.